Death in Yellowstone: Accidents and Foolhardiness in the First National Park, Second Edition

Product Information

Last week, 23-year-old Colin Nathaniel Scott of Portland, Oregon, walked off the designated boardwalks in Yellowstone’s Norris Geyser Basin and fell into one of the park’s acrid, boiling hot springs. The water, some of the hottest in the park at approximately 199 degrees, likely killed him in a matter of moments. At many points in the book, Whittlesey warned his readers that Yellowstone is not an amusement park full of tame animals and guardrails on the trails. It’s a place full of hidden and obvious dangers, he said, which is why he felt compelled to share his cautionary tale while also capturing the park’s colorful history.

Bear-Inflicted Human Injuries and Fatalities in Yellowstone

One of the most gruesome deaths in the park recounted by Whittlesey was a murder in 1889 involving George Trischman, his wife Margaret and their four children. The National Park Service publishes warnings, posts signs and maintains boardwalks where people can walk to get close to popular geyser fields. Yet every year, rangers rescue one or two visitors, frequently small children, who fall from boardwalks or wander off designated paths and punch their feet through thin earthen crust into boiling water. Sign warning of dangerous ground conditions at Norris Geyser Basin in Yellowstone. (Photo: Gloria Wadzinski) It also bears mentioning that there are a lot of bad dog stories in here. Not stories of bad dogs (tho some do show questionable judgement, even for dogs), but bad stories about dogs. Just casually slipped in all over the place. Like dog doo in tall grass, ready to strike when you least expect it. I did not, in fact, see a single mention of a dog that wasn't a complete (dry, pompous, pedantic) horror. So, not for nothing, don't take your dogs to Yellowstone. No good can possibly come of it. Don't argue with me, just get a sitter or go somewhere else. People can’t seem to stay away from the massive bison, with an average of up to five bison encounters per year reported between 1995 and 2012. This may seem strange coming from a person that loves nature, but I was not totally impressed by Yellowstone. I didn’t like thermal pools, not even Old Faithfu, which was surrounded in cement. The Indians never really lived in Yellowstone. Why? The author didn’t say. My own belief is that they didn’t like the thermal pools either.

Deaths and Injuries From Yellowstone Geysers and Hot Springs

Scott's death is the first in 16 years in a Yellowstone thermal feature, the twenty-second on record, according to park officials. But the death comes on the heels of an accident just Saturday evening when a father slipped while carrying his 13-year-old son off trails in the Upper Geyser Basin. A Portland, Oregon, man died Tuesday when he fell into a hot spring at Yellowstone National Park—just three days after a father and son suffered burns after stepping off a path at another Yellowstone thermal attraction. Hank Heasler, principal geologist for the park, said that despite the numerous warnings, posts and signs, rangers end up rescuing one or two visitors – frequently children – from geothermal features each year. I am a teacher so tend not to upbraid people for ignorance, except when they seem persistent in it, or excessively proud of it, and stubborn, and threaten my very existence because of it. I’m tolerant of it with respect to, let’s say, grammar and pronunciation, but not to the extent of Sandy Hook, Holocaust and climate change denial and blind commitments to dangerous conspiracy theories. Sure, the Flat Earth Society is amusing, but not if people are going to die from this idiocy.

Yellowstone Geyser Death Shows Peril of Straying from Boardwalk

Zint, Bradley (April 22, 2016). " 'Population Zero,' debuting at film festival, explores the Zone of Death". Los Angeles Times . Retrieved October 20, 2018. The Zone of Death is the 50-square-mile (130km 2) area in the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park in which, as a result of a reported loophole in the Constitution of the United States, a person can avoid conviction for any major crime, up to and including murder. [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] Loophole [ edit ] but some of them. some of them, you can prevent as long as you are not a fool. like eating plants in yellowstone. seriously, why?? why??

NPT: Why update the book now?

The second half strays away from deaths and accidents that occurred because of Yellowstone and became an account of deaths that happened in the areas close to the park, but not as a direct result of Yellowstone itself. This part was less interesting, not because those people didn't matter, but because the account of their deaths strayed from the premise of the book. In the early 1970s, the parents of Andy Hecht, the nine-year-old who died in Crested Pool, mounted a nationwide campaign to improve national park safety. They eventually settled a wrongful death lawsuit against the National Park Service. A Wyoming judge threw out a lawsuit by Lance Buchi, one of Sara Hulpher’s friends, who was severely burned. Buchi contended that park officials failed to give adequate warning about thermal feature dangers. your risk of dying in an indian battle or stagecoach accident are, admittedly, slim, but lightning, falling trees, earthquakes… you can't prevent this shit from happening.

A Brief History of Deaths in Yellowstone’s Hot Springs

Writing his 1995 book Death in Yellowstone, park historical archivist Lee H. Whittlesey sifted through National Park Service records to identify 19 human fatalities from falling into thermal features. The victims include seven young children who slipped away from parents, teenagers who fell through thin surface crust, fishermen who inadvertently stepped into hot springs near Yellowstone Lake and park concession employees who illegally took “hot pot” swims in thermal pools. Whittlesey was surprised to learn that scaldings posed far more danger in the park than maulings by wild animals. Sadly, the above tragic incident was the second known geyser accident in the park in one week. Earlier in the week, a 13-year-old boy was burned on his ankle and foot on June 6, 2016, after his dad slipped while carrying his son near Old Faithful. The father apparently also suffered burns. According to the National Park Service, the duo had walked off the designated trail in the thermal area. The boy was hospitalized following the incident. Andrews, Robin (November 26, 2017). "A Legal Loophole Might Let You Get Away With Murder In Yellowstone". Forbes . Retrieved October 20, 2018. Moosie never made it out. His body was not recovered, though oils from his body caused small eruptions in the water in the day following.

Murders In The Park

When she returned to the family’s home in Mammoth a few months later, Margaret slashed the throat of her youngest son, nearly severing his head from his body, before chasing the other children with her hunting knife. She was ultimately found to be clinically insane, jumping into the Yellowstone River from the train that was taking her to the hospital in Washington, D.C. Her body was never found. And last of all, we parked along the road where we saw people watching a herd of buffalo. We got out of the car to join them. Now these animals are not fenced in, and after a brief stay, one buffalo headed towards us, and when my husband saw that it was getting too close, he said, “Let’s get out of here before we can’t.” Others remained, even with their children. We were talking about what books were important for tour guiding, and somebody suggested, ‘I know the book that ought to be written – a book about the ways people get themselves killed in the park,’” Whittlesey told the reporter. Turns out, there are many ways to die in Yellowstone, including encounters with wild animals, exposure to noxious fumes, hypothermia, lightening strikes, being hit by falling trees, falls, drownings, accidental shootings, stove explosions and murder. But not always. When discussing the 1986 death of William Tesinsky (by mauling from a grizzly bear) Whittlesey notes, "Bear 59 was a semi habituated bear, ... But she had never even approached a human aggressively." This is not entirely true. I should know, because I was chased by Bear 59 on June 20 of that very year while hiking (alone) between the Grand Canyon of the Yellowstone River and Yellowstone Lake. Indeed, it was my report to the Lake ranger station that led to the temporary closure of that trail, and the bear's eventual relocation by the Park Service. At that time, Bear 59 had two cubs and a large person walking nearby was, as the ranger explained to me, considered a threat. But 59 no longer had the cubs with her when she killed and partially ate the unfortunate Mr. Tesinsky. No doubt, as Whittlesey says, he was too close for 59's liking while trying to get the perfect photograph. But the retelling of this story, that follows the park's official report which I saw a few years later, is interesting in that it does not mention my earlier encounter with 59. Whittlesey the lawyer argues that, much as we don't want to admit it, negligence is more common than accident. He forgot to add that humans, including park rangers, might sometimes unintentionally omit certain bits of information that do not fit their preconceived notions.

Death in ‘Yellowstone’ So Far - We Got This Covered Every Death in ‘Yellowstone’ So Far - We Got This Covered

This a chronicling of "accidents and foolhardiness", with the emphasis put by the author on foolhardiness. It's definitely morbid and the attitude towards the "fools" can be a bit disturbing, but there are some riveting stories here, and they are described in a refreshingly matter-of-fact way. You don't have to embellish too much when your subject matter is people being gored by bison or falling 800 feet to their death. No records exist of Native American injuries or deaths from hot springs, Whittlesey says, though “perhaps it happened.” Before Europeans arrived in the 19th century, according to the park’s official history, local tribes used the hydrothermal waters for medicinal, religious, and practical purposes for hundreds of years. The Dragon’s Mouth stream vent, near the Mud Volcano, was where the Kiowa tribe believed their creator bestowed upon them the Yellowstone area as their home; the Tukudika dipped sheep horns into the springs to make them pliable and suitable for bows. The book strives for a balance between, on the one hand, ensuring visitor safety and preserving wilderness, and on the other hand, entertaining us with stories of massive ignorance that he knows full well will make us shake our heads and snort with laughter. He’s not the best nonfiction story writer, he's not a great storyteller or even writer, but I was distracted for awhile by it from all the other things that can kill me. More serious third-degree burns are suffered by visitors who leave boardwalks and marked trails. They break through the thin surface crust up to their knees and their boots fill with scalding water. Some thermal waters are tepid, but most water temperatures are well above safe levels. People can sit comfortably in hot tub waters heated to between 102 to 105 degrees Fahrenheit, “but above about 120 degrees, you have an increasing chance of getting burned if you go in,” says Steve Sarles, the Yellowstone ranger division’s emergency medical services director. Most hand and foot burns can be treated at local hospitals, but Sarles says one or two people a year suffer more extensive third-degree burns over their bodies after falling into thermal waters with temperatures of 180 degrees or higher. I'll leave this review with a few quotes from the book's ending. "Dangers are simply a part of wilderness. And when one enters wilderness, one must take it on its own terms. Wilderness is impersonal. It does not care whether you live or die. It does not care how much you love it."July 2011 - a day hiker in a party of two was killed by an adult female grizzly bear with 2 cubs on the Wapiti Lake Trail in Hayden Valley. In the end, the massive animal managed to rip off all the man’s clothing and leave 29 horn holes in him.